Judging
What Judges Look For in the American Bully Show Ring
After years of judging American Bully shows across 15+ countries — including the 2019 ABKC Nationals in Houston, the biggest American Bully show in the world — I want to give every exhibitor and owner a clear, honest picture of what happens in the judge's mind from the moment a dog enters the ring.
The First Five Seconds — Silhouette
Before a judge touches a single dog, they form a first impression based on silhouette. How does the dog stand? How does it carry itself? Does the outline immediately read as American Bully?
A strong silhouette draws the judge in. A weak one can put a dog behind before the evaluation even begins. Red flags at a glance include a roached back, straight rear angulation, poor proportions, and weak tail carriage.
Win the silhouette and you start the evaluation ahead.
The Biggest Fault — And It Is Not in the Written Standard
Here is something most people never hear from a judge directly: the biggest fault in the American Bully show ring is not actually written in the ABKC standard. But every serious judge knows it.
The biggest fault of all is a dog that does not conform to the agreed breed type of the American Bully.
If you look at a dog in the ring and it looks like a Bulldog — that is the biggest fault. If it looks like a Pitbull — that is the biggest fault. The dog must look unmistakably like an American Bully. A dog can have correct bone, correct topline, correct tail — but if the overall picture screams Pitbull or Bulldog, it has failed the most fundamental requirement of the show ring.
The Five Aspects of Breed Type
Breed type is evaluated across five areas:
- Breed Character — temperament, presence, confidence
- Silhouette — overall outline and proportions
- Head and Expression — blocky head, deep stop, strong cheeks, correct bite
- Coat — short, stiff, glossy
- Movement — fluid, powerful, correct for the breed
If judges and community members fully understand these five factors, there is no confusion. The standard becomes the judge — not the person holding the clipboard.
Movement — An Area Many Exhibitors Overlook
When I judge an American Bully I am not expecting it to move like a Pitbull, a Bull Terrier, or any other breed. I expect it to move like an American Bully. The breed type defines the movement. A dog that moves correctly for a Pitbull is not necessarily moving correctly for an American Bully.
Going away from the judge, the rear legs should move in a straight, parallel line. Coming toward the judge, the front should show power and reach without weaving. Side movement should show a level topline, good reach, and drive from behind.
Fault Judging vs Holistic Assessment
One of the biggest mistakes a judge can make — and sadly it is very common — is fault judging. This means scanning a dog only to find what is wrong rather than assessing the whole animal.
A fault judge sees an underbite and in their mind that dog automatically loses. But we are not fault finding. We are assessing the whole dog. A dog with a slight underbite that possesses extraordinary breed type, correct structure, effortless movement, and commanding presence may still outshine a dog with a perfect bite but mediocre breed type.
The question a judge should always ask is not — which dog has the fewest faults? The question is — which dog best represents the American Bully breed today?
Personal Preference — The Biggest Pitfall for Judges
The single biggest pitfall for any judge is awarding dogs based on personal preference rather than what is written in the standard. When a judge awards a dog because they personally love that look — not because it best represents the written standard — they are not judging. They are expressing a preference. That is a disservice to the community, to the breed, and to every exhibitor who prepared honestly.
When I step into the ring my personal preferences disappear. The standard is the only voice that matters. The dog that best represents the written breed type wins — regardless of bloodline, regardless of ownership, regardless of personal relationships.
For Exhibitors — Think Like a Judge
Whether you are a new owner or a seasoned exhibitor, the path to consistent winning starts before you ever arrive at a show. Study the standard. Understand breed type. Assess your own dog the way a judge would assess it.
You cannot compete in the show ring seriously without this knowledge. Those who study it consistently are the ones who win consistently — because they already know the answer before the judge picks up the ribbon.
Want to Ask John Directly?
The American Bully Vault puts 20+ years of firsthand knowledge at your fingertips. Ask anything about breeding, showing, health, and standards. Instant answers in 9 languages.
Enter the Vault — $25 Lifetime Access